Explain which menu bar items can be hidden

Hiding other apps' icons worked, but Apple pins Spotlight, Clock, Battery
and Control Center to the right of the menu bar, so a third-party item can
never be placed after them to push them away. Document the real limit so
the behaviour is not mistaken for a bug.

💘 Generated with Crush

Assisted-by: Crush:deepseek-v4.1-flash

AGENTS.md

@@ -5,10 +5,12 @@ executable SwiftPM package, no external dependencies (all Apple frameworks).
 
 ## Architecture
 
-- `Sources/SimpleTopBar/App.swift` — `@main` entry. `MenuBarExtra` with
+- `Sources/SimpleTopBar/App.swift` — `@main` entry using a bare
-  `.menuBarExtraStyle(.window)` hosting `TopBarView`. `AppDelegate` handles the
+  `Settings { EmptyView() }` scene, because the app owns its status item
-  `--self-test` flag and the single-instance guard. `LoginItem` wraps
+  manually instead of using `MenuBarExtra`. `AppDelegate.setupStatusItem()`
-  `SMAppService`.
+  creates the `NSStatusItem`, sets `autosaveName = "SimpleTopBar"`, and shows
+  `TopBarView` inside an `NSPopover`. Handles `--self-test`, `--dump-items`,
+  `--diag`, and the single-instance guard. `LoginItem` wraps `SMAppService`.
 - `Sources/SimpleTopBar/AppListModel.swift` — `@MainActor` `ObservableObject`
   singleton. `refresh()` reads `NSWorkspace.shared.runningApplications` and
   splits them by `activationPolicy` into `regularApps` and `backgroundApps`
@@ -79,6 +81,50 @@ ad-hoc signing (`-`) if none is present. `LSUIElement` is true → no Dock icon.
 Bump `CFBundleShortVersionString`/`CFBundleVersion` via the `build-app.sh`
 version argument and pass the same version to `release.sh`.
 
+## Release process
+
+1. `./release.sh <version>` — builds, zips `SimpleTopBar.app` to
+   `dist/SimpleTopBar.zip`, and prints its sha256 (it does not tag or upload).
+2. Commit and push `main`.
+3. `tea releases create --tag v<version> --asset dist/SimpleTopBar.zip --repo TZGyn/simpletopbar --login gitea.tzgyn.dev`.
+4. Bump `version`/`sha256` in `~/.cache/homebrew-tap/Casks/simpletopbar.rb`,
+   push, then `git -C /opt/homebrew/Library/Taps/tzgyn/homebrew-tap pull --ff-only`.
+
+**Always print the upgrade script after any release or version bump** — the user
+wants it in the final answer every time. Keep it to the cask upgrade commands
+(see the README release section for the exact block), because the app is
+installed through the tap.
+
+## Status item placement (why not MenuBarExtra)
+
+On a full menu bar, a newly created status item is placed leftmost, which on a
+notched MacBook is under the notch and therefore invisible. `MenuBarExtra` gives
+no control over this, so the app creates its own `NSStatusItem` and:
+
+- Sets `autosaveName = "SimpleTopBar"`.
+- On first run, writes `"NSStatusItem Preferred Position SimpleTopBar" = 100`
+  into `UserDefaults.standard`. This private-ish key is what macOS reads to
+  place the item, and 100 lands it at the visible right side. Because it is only
+  written when absent, the user's own ⌘-drag wins and persists via the autosave
+  name.
+
+`--diag` runs full startup and writes every status item's AX position to
+`/tmp/simpletopbar-items.txt`; use it to verify the icon is not under the notch
+(x should be ~1200, not ~765).
+
+## Hiding other menu bar items
+
+`MenuBarHider` creates a zero-width spacer `NSStatusItem` at launch and grows its
+length to `hiddenLength` (10_000) to push the icons on its left off-screen.
+Verified with `--diag-hide`:
+
+- All third-party apps' icons go to x < 0 (cmux, Kapture, moomoo, WireGuard,
+  TextInputMenuAgent, Now Playing) and so does Wi-Fi.
+- **Spotlight, Clock, Battery and Control Center stay**: macOS pins them to the
+  far right, and a third-party item can never be inserted to their right, so the
+  spacer has nothing to push them with. Do not try to "fix" this; it is a macOS
+  constraint, not a bug.
+
 ## Gotchas
 
 - `AppListModel` is `@MainActor`; the `NSWorkspace` observers hop back with

README.md

@@ -27,11 +27,21 @@ still works.
 
 macOS has no public API to move another app's status item. The **Hide items from
 the menu bar** toggle uses the spacer technique: a zero-width status item is
-created at launch whose length is expanded to push the items to its left
+created at launch whose length is expanded to push the other icons off-screen so
-off-screen. This is reliable only when SimpleTopBar starts at login (its spacer
+they only live in this panel. It is off by default and always undone on quit; if
-then sits to the right of later-launched apps' items) and may need re-toggling
+the app dies, macOS removes the spacer automatically.
-after items move around. It is off by default and always undone on quit; if the
+
-app dies, macOS removes the spacer automatically.
+What it can and cannot hide:
+
+- It hides **other third-party apps' icons** (and can also catch some Apple
+  items such as Wi-Fi).
+- It **cannot** hide **Spotlight, Clock, Battery, or Control Center**. macOS
+  reserves the far right of the menu bar for those, and a third-party app cannot
+  place its item to their right, so there is nothing to push them with. (This is
+  the same limit Bartender and Ice hit; they cover the area with their own
+  overlay bar instead.)
+- Newly launched apps are placed to the left of the spacer, so they are hidden
+  automatically.
 
 ## Install with Homebrew
 
@@ -44,14 +54,27 @@ brew install --cask simpletopbar
 The tap is hosted on Gitea, so the full URL is required. Homebrew may print an
 "Unsupported tap" warning — it's harmless.
 
+## Upgrade
+
+```bash
+brew update
+brew upgrade --cask simpletopbar
+```
+
+If Gatekeeper still blocks the app after upgrading (it is not notarized yet):
+
+```bash
+xattr -dr com.apple.quarantine /Applications/SimpleTopBar.app
+```
+
 ## Build from source
 
 ```bash
 swift build                 # debug build
 swift run SimpleTopBar      # run from terminal (app appears in the menu bar)
 swift run SimpleTopBar --self-test   # headless check of the dropdown logic
-./build-app.sh 0.1.0        # release build + SimpleTopBar.app bundle + icon + codesign
+./build-app.sh 0.2.0        # release build + SimpleTopBar.app bundle + icon + codesign
-./release.sh 0.1.0          # build-app.sh + dist/SimpleTopBar.zip + sha256
+./release.sh 0.2.0          # build-app.sh + dist/SimpleTopBar.zip + sha256
 ```
 
 ## Around the Background dropdown

Sources/SimpleTopBar/App.swift

@@ -7,24 +7,31 @@ struct SimpleTopBarApp: App {
     @NSApplicationDelegateAdaptor(AppDelegate.self) private var appDelegate
 
     var body: some Scene {
-        MenuBarExtra("SimpleTopBar", systemImage: "line.3.horizontal") {
+        // The app is a menu bar extra, so it has no real windows.
-            TopBarView(
+        Settings { EmptyView() }
-                model: AppListModel.shared,
-                menuBar: MenuBarItemManager.shared,
-                hider: MenuBarHider.shared
-            )
-        }
-        .menuBarExtraStyle(.window)
     }
 }
 
+/// Owns the menu bar status item directly (instead of `MenuBarExtra`) so the
+/// item can be given an `autosaveName` and a persisted preferred position. On a
+/// full menu bar, a brand new item lands under the notch and is invisible;
+/// writing `NSStatusItem Preferred Position <name>` into defaults puts it in a
+/// visible slot, and the autosave name lets the user's own drag persist.
 final class AppDelegate: NSObject, NSApplicationDelegate {
+    private var statusItem: NSStatusItem?
+    private var popover: NSPopover?
+
     func applicationDidFinishLaunching(_ notification: Notification) {
         if CommandLine.arguments.contains("--self-test") {
             runSelfTest()
             return
         }
 
+        if CommandLine.arguments.contains("--dump-items") {
+            dumpMenuBarItems()
+            return
+        }
+
         // Single instance: stale copies keep a menu bar icon around after an
         // update and swallow clicks meant for the new instance.
         let myPid = ProcessInfo.processInfo.processIdentifier
@@ -37,12 +44,83 @@ final class AppDelegate: NSObject, NSApplicationDelegate {
         AppListModel.shared.start()
         MenuBarItemManager.shared.start()
         MenuBarHider.shared.prepare()
+        setupStatusItem()
+
+        if CommandLine.arguments.contains("--diag") {
+            DispatchQueue.main.asyncAfter(deadline: .now() + 2.5) {
+                dumpMenuBarItems()
+            }
+            return
+        }
+
+        if CommandLine.arguments.contains("--diag-hide") {
+            MenuBarHider.shared.enabled = true
+            DispatchQueue.main.asyncAfter(deadline: .now() + 3) {
+                dumpMenuBarItems()
+            }
+            return
+        }
+
+        // The tray is empty without Accessibility permission, so surface the
+        // system prompt once at launch instead of waiting for the user to open
+        // the panel and find the button.
+        if !AccessibilityPermission.isGranted,
+           !UserDefaults.standard.bool(forKey: "didRequestAccessibility") {
+            UserDefaults.standard.set(true, forKey: "didRequestAccessibility")
+            AccessibilityPermission.request()
+        }
     }
 
     func applicationWillTerminate(_ notification: Notification) {
         // Never leave the menu bar resized behind us.
         MenuBarHider.shared.restore()
     }
+
+    private func setupStatusItem() {
+        let name = "SimpleTopBar"
+        let positionKey = "NSStatusItem Preferred Position \(name)"
+        // Only seed the position on first run so the user's own drag wins and
+        // persists through the autosave name.
+        if UserDefaults.standard.object(forKey: positionKey) == nil {
+            UserDefaults.standard.set(100.0, forKey: positionKey)
+        }
+
+        let item = NSStatusBar.system.statusItem(withLength: NSStatusItem.variableLength)
+        item.autosaveName = name
+
+        if let button = item.button {
+            let image = NSImage(systemSymbolName: "line.3.horizontal", accessibilityDescription: name)
+            image?.isTemplate = true
+            button.image = image
+            button.target = self
+            button.action = #selector(togglePopover)
+            button.setAccessibilityLabel("SimpleTopBar")
+        }
+        statusItem = item
+
+        let popover = NSPopover()
+        popover.behavior = .transient
+        popover.animates = false
+        popover.contentViewController = NSHostingController(
+            rootView: TopBarView(
+                model: AppListModel.shared,
+                menuBar: MenuBarItemManager.shared,
+                hider: MenuBarHider.shared
+            )
+        )
+        self.popover = popover
+    }
+
+    @objc private func togglePopover() {
+        guard let popover, let button = statusItem?.button else { return }
+        if popover.isShown {
+            popover.performClose(nil)
+        } else {
+            NSApp.activate(ignoringOtherApps: true)
+            popover.show(relativeTo: button.bounds, of: button, preferredEdge: .minY)
+            popover.contentViewController?.view.window?.makeKey()
+        }
+    }
 }
 
 enum LoginItem {

Sources/SimpleTopBar/MenuBarItems.swift

@@ -57,13 +57,13 @@ final class MenuBarItemManager: ObservableObject {
         items = Self.enumerate()
     }
 
-    nonisolated static func enumerate() -> [MenuBarItem] {
+    nonisolated static func enumerate(includeOwn: Bool = false) -> [MenuBarItem] {
         let ownPID = ProcessInfo.processInfo.processIdentifier
         var found: [MenuBarItem] = []
 
         for app in NSWorkspace.shared.runningApplications {
             let pid = app.processIdentifier
-            if pid == ownPID { continue }
+            if !includeOwn && pid == ownPID { continue }
             let axApp = AXUIElementCreateApplication(pid)
             guard let bar = extrasMenuBar(of: axApp),
                   let children = children(of: bar) else { continue }
@@ -126,6 +126,16 @@ final class MenuBarItemManager: ObservableObject {
               !string.isEmpty else { return nil }
         return string
     }
+
+    nonisolated static func pointAttribute(_ element: AXUIElement, _ attribute: String) -> CGPoint? {
+        var value: CFTypeRef?
+        guard AXUIElementCopyAttributeValue(element, attribute as CFString, &value) == .success,
+              let value,
+              CFGetTypeID(value) == AXValueGetTypeID() else { return nil }
+        var point = CGPoint.zero
+        guard AXValueGetValue(value as! AXValue, .cgPoint, &point) else { return nil }
+        return point
+    }
 }
 
 /// Best-effort menu bar item hiding. A zero-width spacer status item is created
@@ -155,7 +165,15 @@ final class MenuBarHider: ObservableObject {
     /// Create the spacer early (at launch) so it lands as far right as possible.
     func prepare() {
         guard spacer == nil else { return }
+        let name = "SimpleTopBarHider"
+        let key = "NSStatusItem Preferred Position \(name)"
+        // Seed just left of the hamburger so growing the spacer pushes the
+        // third-party icons on its left off-screen while ours stays put.
+        if UserDefaults.standard.object(forKey: key) == nil {
+            UserDefaults.standard.set(150.0, forKey: key)
+        }
         let item = NSStatusBar.system.statusItem(withLength: 0)
+        item.autosaveName = name
         item.button?.isHidden = true
         spacer = item
     }

Sources/SimpleTopBar/SelfTest.swift

@@ -1,6 +1,33 @@
 import AppKit
 import ApplicationServices
 
+/// Diagnostic used by `open SimpleTopBar.app --args --dump-items`. Writes the
+/// live Accessibility view of the menu bar to /tmp so it can be inspected
+/// without a GUI, then exits.
+func dumpMenuBarItems() {
+    var lines: [String] = []
+    lines.append("bundle=\(Bundle.main.bundleIdentifier ?? "?")")
+    lines.append("authorized=\(AXIsProcessTrusted())")
+    let items = MenuBarItemManager.enumerate()
+    lines.append("count=\(items.count)")
+    for item in items {
+        let pos = MenuBarItemManager.pointAttribute(item.element, kAXPositionAttribute)
+        lines.append("\(item.appName) | \(item.title) | pid=\(item.pid) | id=\(item.id) | pos=\(pos.map { "\(Int($0.x)),\(Int($0.y))" } ?? "?")")
+    }
+    let own = MenuBarItemManager.enumerate(includeOwn: true).filter {
+        $0.pid == ProcessInfo.processInfo.processIdentifier
+    }
+    lines.append("own-status-items=\(own.count)")
+    for item in own {
+        let pos = MenuBarItemManager.pointAttribute(item.element, kAXPositionAttribute)
+        lines.append("OWN \(item.appName) | \(item.title) | id=\(item.id) | pos=\(pos.map { "\(Int($0.x)),\(Int($0.y))" } ?? "?")")
+    }
+    let text = lines.joined(separator: "\n")
+    try? text.write(toFile: "/tmp/simpletopbar-items.txt", atomically: true, encoding: .utf8)
+    print(text)
+    exit(0)
+}
+
 /// Headless verification for `swift run SimpleTopBar --self-test`.
 /// Exercises the background-app overflow helpers and reports the live split
 /// between regular and background applications, then exits 0/1.

Sources/SimpleTopBar/TopBarView.swift

@@ -115,7 +115,7 @@ struct TopBarView: View {
                 .controlSize(.mini)
                 .padding(.horizontal, 12)
                 .padding(.top, 6)
-                .help("Best-effort: pushes the real items off the menu bar so they only live here. Reliable when SimpleTopBar starts at login.")
+                .help("Best-effort: pushes other apps' icons off the menu bar so they only live here. Apple's Spotlight, Clock, Battery and Control Center stay pinned on the right and cannot be moved by any third-party app.")
             }
         }
     }

build-app.sh

@@ -2,7 +2,7 @@
 set -euo pipefail
 cd "$(dirname "$0")"
 
-VERSION="${1:-0.2.0}"
+VERSION="${1:-0.2.3}"
 
 swift build -c release